Whilst the ‘Rise and Fall’ Chapters tell the story as we fans saw the rise and fall of a group and the formal fan clubs, it reflects the known feelings and comments of both former group members and fan club promoters. As Casey Chameleon, I have turned from my pseudonym for a reflective afterthought that brings the reader back to the bigger picture of today’s continuing thirst for unheard music that had become obvious was being held back from us as fans. Obviously as has been said it is up to the artist and music owners to decide what they want heard of their musical efforts and not all would live up to the high standards they set for releases. And there are ownership and royalties issues which can be difficult to overcome.
Unlike a standard "Conclusion" section which recaps data and findings, a ‘research coda’ serves specific structural and thematic purposes. It is aimed at ‘Bridging Timelines’ as it connects the "past world" of our data collection and the books ‘historical account’ to the "present world" and the current writing context of our ‘Historical Society’. It is a ‘Supplement’, and ‘Not a Summary’: It does not just restate our story. It adds a final layer of depth, commentary, or philosophical significance to the context of both the group of the late 1970s…..the pathway of group line-ups since and today’s fans to the creation of the Snapper Music Box Set and further aims of the Society for future generations. It is also a Personal Reflection by Ken Charmer as our primary researcher since 1997, to step out of the strict ‘storyline’ to explain what the overall ‘timeline of events’ means to you as a fan and the barriers overcome and those moving forward. The "What Happened Next" factor is shown in ‘bullet point’ paragraphs as it addresses ongoing real-world actions, long-term impacts, or events that unfolded after our formal story which concluded in 2009. The result of these events would be the Box Set release in June 2023 in agreement with the Four Seasons Partnership and Snapper Music, Rhino, Universal Motown and Warner-Curb
_______________________________________________________
Part 1 – The roots of the Box Set
1995 and a Bootleg Studio based vinyl transfer CD of the Motown Tracks [‘The Night/Inside You’ albums] appears for the very first time in Europe since the 1991 Superstars CD. It was a reaction by the late Stefan Wriedt to the failure by both Universal Motown and The Four Seasons partnership to release any of the work under contract at MoWest/Motown
1997 and the accidental finding of ‘One Man’ Master in the Philips Vaults which Peter Bennet [FSP Attorney] refuted as being Frankie and the group. This was the ‘denial’ that became the germination of a project.
As the UK fan group former members sought a web based presence and official recognition Peter Bennett issued a ‘cease and desist’ order to prevent this and our use of images, which he maintained had copyright issues. He subsequently relented and offers funds to the fan club for an ‘official’ status …….provided they do not speak to ex Four Seasons. The offer is refused. The group stays independent and seeks interviews with former Four Seasons Joe Long and John Paiva.
2001 -Receipt by Ken Charmer of the first ‘Unreleased List’ via a Yahoo group fan with paper based record supposedly of the Motown Tape Vault Database. A list later from former Motown Interns [the names are known but protected with anonymity] confirmed the full Frankie Valli and Four Seasons Session Tape listing at Motown with Tapes and tracks identified
2002 – Paul Nixon proposed a ‘Four Seasons ‘Unreleased’ research project’ and release to Harry Weinger(CEO) at Universal Motown
2002 - Confirmation by Bob Gaudio in phone interview with Stu Miller 2002 that unreleased tracks existed and that he had spoken to Harry Weinger but no new releases happened after of any of the ‘Unreleased’ recordings Bob Gaudio knew of. These were from both the early 1970s and 2000 recording sessions.
The Jersey Boys stage show is launched 2004? [and subsequently as a ‘film’]. The World-Wide success and huge income understandably diverts any interest by the FSP in any ‘Unreleased’ tracks
A Review of Studio Masters on CD compared to the original vinyl releases was completed by Sound Engineer – Stefan Wriedt in 2006, showing the need for investment in an updated Digital Master Library Preservation project
With JB at it’s height the Jersey Beat Box Set 2 CD Box Set is issued in 2007 - but with over-compression and poor sound quality on many tracks.
2007 - A UK project is launched with Paul Nixon [renowned Motown CD set compiler] to get a Motown Unreleased CD set issued. Motown confirm Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli must be in agreement. All proposed tracks are based on the previous ‘anonymous’ supply of the Tape Index , identifying tracks and production tape locations with up to 40 unheard alternative versions and unreleased tracks needing research
Peter Bennett [FSP Attorney] challenges Universal Motown ownership of any unreleased tracks and confirms all are “demos or unfinished….or out of key”.
Harry Weinger takes control and meets Bob Gaudio again
Gaudio agrees to a 2 CD Box Set of ‘released only’ tracks with a separate CD ‘to be recorded’ as a Frankie Valli SOLO album
2008 brings release of a Motown Anthology [2 CD Box] and ‘Romancing The Sixties’ Frankie Valli SOLO. The actual Anthology is of the released tracks but contains 2 unreleased ‘alternate versions’ previously unheard except on demo acetate. Harry Weinger agrees there were no unreleased tracks included ‘that were slated for release’. This was a ‘play on words’ piece of mis-information.
2010 Acetates surface transferred on to cassette tape of 3 songs completed by Bob Crewe in 1973 from Collector’s which had never been heard by the majority of fans. They confirm entries in the Tape Index as titles recorded. I re-mastered them as well as it was possible given the source and put them on You Tube and ask the question “why are they unreleased? They are so good.”
2011 Artists Cards arrived from a Universal Motown researcher contact who copied them from microfiche in Motown’s Vaults records. They correspond with the Tape Index and that tracks were completed and on 16 track session Master Tapes with several also copied to Safety Tapes[T Tapes]
2012 - Our German Sound Engineer Stefan Wriedt starts to studio dub the 1960s MONO 45s from mint vinyl for a fan club based MONO ARCHIVE. This takes till 2016 during which period he sadly passes away with liver cancer.
2012 - I start the ‘Four Seasons Motown Unreleased Campaign’ Facebook group to publicise and share with ‘the world of fans’ on the internet what we have found, what can be heard on You Tube and what remains hidden.
2018 I get a phone call from Snapper Records of London who say they have a concept proposal agreed in principle with the ‘majors’ [i.e. Rhino and Universal] and ‘Frankie and Bob’ and they want the UK Fan club to help research and compile it.
Lynn Boleyn and I meet the co-ordinator and Executive Director with Bob Fisher[ex Motown, Charly, Westside, and Sequel et al]. Fisher was one of the industry’s most highly-regarded catalogue experts.
Asked what we wanted in a catalogue wide Box Set of 40+ CD’s Lynn replied….’The Motown Unreleased’. We signed up to help in any way we could with donation of tracks we had collected from ‘unreleased’ sources …memorabilia and disc scans…......on a hand-shake.
END OF PART 1
Part 2 – The Project Process
The BIG picture re the Snapper Box Set Project, from the perspective of Bob Fisher and I, involved 2 objectives:-
To find and decide upon the BEST Master to be used in the Box Set....for each of the albums. To check the tapes were complete with no tracks 'pulled'. Also with other non-LP tapes to establish if the versions were unique and alternative to the album versions
To find as many Unreleased Tracks as possible - from sessions or LIVE Tapes so that the Box Set was sufficiently different to past releases - and was as comprehensive an Anthology as is possible
Snapper acknowledged these via Project Co-Ordinator Ian Crocket and so below are the key milestones of how we developed the Project from my perspective
Bill Inglot was commissioned [at Bob Gaudio’s request] to do a thorough research of the FSP storage in LA to find the original album Master tapes. A chronological album list is compiled and transfers to the UK Mastering Engineer ‘Reynolds Mastering’ began. It soon became clear that no comprehensive catalogue listing of the FSP archive existed and that ALL of the album Masters were Safety Copies possibly 2 or 3 generations from the masters. The original album masters it appeared were either at the original studios - or destroyed as we were told re the Bell Studio Masters and the status of other labels was unclear except for Vee-Jay as copies of the MONO and STEREO tracks were supplied as ‘Delivery Tapes’ when the label went bust in 1966. Bill Inglot also searched out any other tape boxes with notes indicating Four Seasons or Frankie Valli references for transfer. HITS albums or non-original compilations were not to be included but some would be flagged for research for alternative versions : where different : and to ID special mixes on 45 that were especially ‘unique’
‘None album’ Masters were ‘flagged up’ for research and transfers copied to Bob Fisher and I for evaluation.
That process ran through the Vee-Jay and Philips, Private Stock and Warner-Curb [et al] analogue tapes, with all being Safety Copies as Bill Inglot advised, only 3 tapes of ‘multi-track studio session tapes’ existed in the FSP Archive. These were at the end of the Philips contract collection compiled when they left Philips.[by engineer Ken Roberts] Some 20 plus multi-track titles were also on tape but advised of as only instrumental tracks with no vocals.
We highlighted the Motown Tape Index is of Multi-track Sessions[16 track with all ‘studio ‘takes’’] and STEREO/MONO test mixes and of the many unreleased identified as potentially being there and an agreement/contract was placed by Snapper to pull the tapes from the Iron Mountain Vault Storage listed in our compiled Tape Index list to identify contents of ‘unreleased’ tracks. None of the research of Tape Box listings by Vault Services at Universal Motown by Andy Skurow was shared with Bob Fisher and I except one Tape Box scan by Andy [at Vault Services] and a list of 19 tracks with vocals listed and a possible 11 more. Not all paper record tapes on Artists Cards and T tapes.[Safety copies] were reviewed.
Covid delayed research and transfers in 2019/2020...in the meantime, John Pingree supplied his memorabilia, Lynn Boleyn scans of albums and picture sleeves, me ….unreleased tracks collected and rare photos …..and Ray Nichol dubs of missing MONO 45 Masters not in the FSP Storage. We agree to supply a set of Collectors Notes re the history of the recordings included.
There was initially a lack of willingness by Bob Gaudio to review 16 track Motown Multi-track tapes and a set of digital transfers of ‘tapes’ was sent to him based on ‘titles’ for him and Frankie to review and see what they remembered on the list. No confirmation of what of the 29 Motown tapes identified were supplied. We never got any further data.
2020 - 14 tracks are approved by Bob Gaudio for inclusion…following whatever research he and his son Shannon undertook..and one is [almost immediately] rescinded [I Will Love You Like A Man] No explanation was given leaving us to ‘speculate’ that this was a ‘politically correct’ decision related to the male gender in the title.
Masters of 13 Motown ‘Unreleased’ mixes are shared with Bob Fisher and I, and some duplicates were also found amongst the Storage in LA as ‘listening mix copies’ supplied in 1973 to Bob Gaudio. They turned out to be ‘alternate’ mixes to the 13 approved and some of the actual released. Permission was sought to include them in addition to the 13 tracks and 22 tracks became the final CD set. They can be heard here.
Snapper decided to not pursue further tracks [just the LA stored tracks] and urged Bob Fisher and I to research more ‘Unreleased’ from the LA storage. Early 2021 arrived with the project delayed due to Covid and other Snapper Projects. Mastering had not started except for some sample albums which revealed some problems re the 1960s tape quality and sources. The Engineer asked for one missing track in the transfers…..and we submitted 4 sets of ‘fan group’ collected ‘unreleased’ songs for inclusion[circa 30].
Bill Inglot was pushed to find more in the LA Storage and unearthed several unreleased acetates from 1969 and alternate versions to the albums and 45 issues. These including [at last] ‘Killing Time’ [a long known mid 1980s cassette based unreleased find you can hear here] and the STEREO version of ‘Goodnight My Love’ [which last appeared on the ‘Looking Back’ album in 1966] I had been asking for these from day one
A final list was compiled for 44 CD’s with the vinyl MONO GILG and sent to Bob Gaudio in May 2022 for approval. He approved all but 4 tracks[Charisma EXTENDED, East Meets West DEMO, I Still Care DEMO, and another I can’t remember]
The list of over 830 tracks contained ‘tape location’ data re all transferred or supplied digital MASTERS that I had agreed with Bob Fisher[the then Project Producer] as the ‘best quality sound’ versions as Master Track Advisor on behalf of the fans. With regard to this....... the decision to use the ‘Vee-Jay Delivery Tapes’ [from 1966] by Bob Fisher and I was based on our listening tests of VJ Reels 5 MONO and STEREO and the fact that these Masters were significantly better than any CD release to date....so I identified each track to re-compile the VJ albums which I was told the engineer has followed.
Bob Fisher sadly passed away after a heart attack on October 7th 2021
Co-ordination of the contents and mastering was with Snapper’s in-house ‘credits and publishing’ team and I had no further contact with Snapper Records [we had lost our PRODUCER] until a call with co-ordinator Ian Crocket in May 2022 re final drafts and masters was sent to me…...all produced by others with their quality control systems.
I reviewed a draft ‘proof copy’ to discover 7 missed tracks, with publication, production and release
Snapper reviewed my comments and agreed to re-instate all 7. Mastering samples of 4 completed Discs were supplied. I advised 2 were excellent and 2 below the standard expected. Snapper changed the ‘Bachelors III’ LIVE concert to the one I had supplied.
Production and release was delayed till June 2023 due to vinyl pressing plant backlog.
Part 3 – The Final Product Content Review – Music content
The Bonus Tracks – are not as supplied in a few cases and two tracks are missing
The missed or wrong Masters are advised to Snapper who do not have plans to share this information
I discover missing annotation in Andy Skurow’s Motown Tracks and publish the corrections on our blog
The Mastering and Sound Quality is below expectations with the 60s Master Tapes and Mastering Processing from 1962 to 1967 [on the first 12 albums re-mastered by the Snapper Engineer -in my opinion] and there are obvious problems found by a sound quality check and published in our blog for fans. A log of location of the best issued Masters of these tracks is supplied in blogs for releases on CD of the best sound quality versions of original album 1962 to 1967, so fans can find these if they want the best ‘masters’ digitally.
The Book and Artwork Content has some ‘typo’ errors but all too late to correct
Whatever the final co-ordination issues were and my attempts to fix errors, this project was a major ‘masterpiece’. The results in the Box Set are a ‘Living Legacy’, and those who own this 44 CD Box Set with Books and Vinyl insert can reflect on how this music changes the artist's history. What it means for these voices to be heard today instead of rotting in a dark room is what the decades have resulted in since Eliot Goshman of Tarragon Records had found in the Philips Archives and sent to Ken Charmer. A copy of the raw Studio Master of ‘One Man’ in 1997 [that can be heard here]. That started the search and the timeline above shows the pathway to today
In Oxton near Liverpool I reflect on my opening of the Box Set with my son Mark
As a personal reflection, hunting through these tape vault transfers simply reinforced my view that the creators and owners of the music do not care enough to invest in their story whilst I did with other fans who searched out any potential sources. And thanks particularly to my dear friend and former Four Season John Paiva we were able to tell this story and hear their ‘unheard’ magic.[He even visited me in Spain]
I simply had to do all I could to preserve this period in our lives as a music lover? Now thanks to Snapper Music and a ‘relenting’ Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli the released and previously unreleased music is something that is now alive, out in the world, and no longer trapped in the past or in storage or old cassettes. This project is not over though and for some Sound Engineer in the future he could experience ……….’the smell of the deteriorating tape boxes as they are opened’……..or ‘the restoration process’ ……..or even ‘the search for antique analogue tape machines’, but for us fans hearing the unreleased would be ……….‘the silence in the room right before the previously unheard music is played’ …….’the anticipation’. THE SEARCH GOES ON!!!!
Ken Charmer -Master Track Advisor for the Snapper Music Box Set – Web Researcher and Music Historian for The Four Seasons Historical Society